Big Cat Country: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Cal RB Jahvid Best Seriously Injured, Carted Off Field

Game Review: NCAA Football 2009

[Note by River City Rage, 07/14/08 1:15 PM EDT ]FSBlueApocalypse reviewed NCAA 2008 for us.  It's the dead zone, though this game is usually the first sign that real honest-to-goodness football is around the corner. -Chris

Time to bust out your kegs and start your tailgating, College football season is here!

(Author’s note: This review is based off the Playstation 3 and Xbox 360 versions of the game)

  270176b_medium 200432b_medium

 

 

Ah, NCAA Football, Madden’s little yet superior brother. While any competitive Madden game usually ends with 3 yards and a cloud of dust football, the sheer amount of ways to play in NCAA has always made it more unpredictable.

However, NCAA football has had somewhat of a difficult transition to current generation systems. To call NCAA Football 2007 for the XBOX 360 a barebones affair would be fair, and a rushed POS that had features needlessly dropped would be true. NCAA Football 2008 for the PS3 had its own share of problems, including its broken online play, PS2 level graphics, and an overall less polished feel than its 360 counterpart. So, has NCAA finally found its legs?


The Bad

I hate it when reviews go on and on about how good a game is, than the last 2 paragraphs highlight everything wrong, then leave you wondering why it got a 9.5/10. This and since I’m already spewing bile, so I’ll just go ahead with the bad.

  1. The micromanaging has returned once again.

Whenever you go into Dynasty mode, even before you kickoff for your first game, you have to go and select recruits to try and get during the season, try to formulate game plans, etc. Now, if you’re into this stuff, I’m sure you’ll love it, but I prefer you know, actually playing games.

  1. The computer is once again retarded.

If you played the campus legend mode, your teammates will once again be about as much help as lobotomized chimpanzees. In addition, to the above mentioned micromanaging, you technically can have the game do it for you. However, it has a lovely habit of skipping over that 5 star running back begging to come to your school for a 1 star free safety because your second stringer is graduating.

  1. Broken CPU players

For those not well versed in gamer speak, Broken basicly means its either garbage or seriously over powered. In the case of the former, even on All American or Heisman difficulty setting, DL rarely get through your OL, cornerbacks will get beat on a fly route by any receiver with speed over 90, and the crème de le crème of my experience, running a play action 6 times in a row and the safety bit every time.

For an example of the latter, meet Tim Tebow ladies and gentlemen. I guess EA bought all the stuff about him being Superman. Tebow is so ridiculously overpowered, and I won’t even get to partner in crime Percy Harvin, that Florida will probably be banned from every competitive NCAA tournament this year. Case in point, my friend ran the shotgun QB draw with Tebow 3 time in a row, each time gaining 7+ yards, then had him throw a perfect pass to Harvin in double coverage for a TD.

Ncaa-football-09-20080625032423084_640w_medium

 

In addition, the rubberband AI in this game can be ridiculous as times. You could be USC beating Sisters of the blind 42-0 in the 4th, and you’ll think their team transformed into the all-time greatest football players ever and mount a furious comeback.

The Good

  1. Deep Gameplay

As has always been the case with NCAA, the multitude of ways to play and master will keep you coming back for more. You can run the spread option with West Virginia, the spread shotgun with Missouri, a pro style offense with USC, the air attack with Texas Tech, and many more.

  1. Online Dynasty

Easily the biggest addition to the franchise is the addition of the online dynasty mode. It adds a lot of know that instead of competing for that 5 star QB of the future with the computer, another person could be using it against you. In addition, it makes the mandatory 5 minute quarters easier to tolerate to know you’re trying to win a title in a league full of people, rather than just trying to get onto a national leader board.

Whether playing on the Playstation Network or Xbox Live, NCAA 2008 was notorious for server crashes, lag, and downright unplayability. This has been eliminated. In our first week of conference games, my league had 6 games going on at once, not only did we not see any lag/hiccups; we were also alerted to real time updates of the other games in progress. For once EA managed to deliver on its promise.

  1. Presentation

Finally we have a NCAA Football game that looks like it belongs on current generation systems. Both the PS3 and 360 versions run at a silky smooth 60 frames per second, and with a supposed claim of being 1080p native, though I have somewhat of a life and haven’t bothered to look and see if that’s true or not. Graphics look great on both systems, though I give a slight edge to the PS3 as the shadows, lighting, and crowds look more natural and better in motion.

  Ncaa-football-09-20080425022438979_640w_medium

 

The Ugly

Roster Updates

Most of us can’t stand to look at UF QB#15 or FSU SS #2 for very long, and have added home made rosters to change it. EA seemingly listened to our cries and added the Locker Room, a place to upload rosters to a central server to let you do it nice and easy. However, in several attempts to try this feature, it simply crashed the game and made me start over again.

Player disappearances

I’m not sure if they’re abducted by aliens or what, but players will occasionally be deleted from your roster with no warning at all. I’m not talking about just juniors who are draft eligible, but everyone from new recruits to returning seniors.

The Verdict

As much hating as I’ve done for the game, I did enjoy it. Online Dynasty mode is awesome and gives the series a much needed injection of freshness that the series has needed. To EA’s credit, they have promised patches for the various game play issues, hopefully before Madden comes out this year. Overall, I’d say this year’s version if the first current generation version to have $60 legs and should provide you a full years worth of entertainment.

 

8.5/10

Poll
Which series do you prefer
NCAA
32 votes
Madden
94 votes
Any Non-EA football game (Damn Monopoly)
10 votes

136 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Has anyone played..

the game using UCLA as their team? Just curious how they are rated.

by Ewdtrey on Jul 14, 2008 2:09 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

WHAT?

tebow can’t fly????? the game is a joke…

by jlana24 on Jul 14, 2008 4:34 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

It's been tested.

Tebow can only be tackled by 12 players at a time. Only way to stop him is to use the Mascot as the 12th man.

-C

Big Cat Country!:: The Official Home of the Unofficial Blog of the Jacksonville Jaguars!

by River City Rage on Jul 14, 2008 5:32 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Division 2

One thing i loved about the previous NCAA (not last years) was the Division 2 schools they had. Do they have all those kinds of teams again this year?

by jnunez on Jul 14, 2008 4:36 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Big Cat Country:: Jacksonville Jaguars news, commentary, speculation and fun, all from a fan's perspective
Start posting about the Jaguars »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

J_page_small
Arrowhead Pride answers your questions about the Chiefs
Board_small
Jaguars' Coach Jack Del Rio: Weighed, Measured and Found Wanting

Recent FanPosts

Jacksonvillejaguars2_small
some weird questons
King_crimson_-_larks_small
Maybe the Jaguars aren't so bad at pass rushing
Go_jags_2_small
The Eraser
Art-disguise_small
You Can't Draft Ticket Sales
Kép_008_small
Being the Devil's advocate-my view on the Jack Del Rio watch
Spags_victory_small
3k from Turf Show Times back for some mock help
Dscf0987_small
It is time to say good-bye
Rc9ubca0n5jbncalor6ipcaeoow8scapb9djjcajqq8vjcaj39wbpcanrq9hncauk2hepcax6gnl8cadr98u6cauaqzgzcaxta3ddcawuv9nbcalkc6kmcast1rh1ca4svkemca14mepcca8gp318cai4htzy_small
Diamonds in the Rough: Players to Watch for in 2010 Draft

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Turf Show Times
Random Ramsdom: Nov 9th, 2009
Behind the Steel Curtain
BTSC Weekly NFL Musings - Week 9 Edition
Blogging The Boys
Understudy Sunday: the Cowboys Outslug the Eagles 20-16

Founder

Delriosad_small River City Rage

Editor-in-Chief

Picture_007_edited_small silencecs

Associate Editor

Pict0319_small Tkopa

Duke_small FSBlueApocalypse

Jaguar_growl_small JvilleJag2