Now here is my reaction point by point:

Garrard and Jack and the playcalling-If we would won; this would be a no issue. So I’m not take it seriously so much.

Harvey: Well I’m not optimistic about him. Sorry. Untill he proves me otherwise he is a big bust-because the jaguars gave 5 picks for trading him up and the result is 0. Sorry; he need to start sack the QB or trade him until you could (Reggie Williams anyone?)

Hitting David: Major concern! The left side of the O-line is an shaky territory (to say the least). If Monroe (or Thomas) cannot protect him; I might start to join the pick a QB wwith the 1st rounder group-And I’m hate that idea…

Jack’s talent evaluation. He was good in the earyl phases. No I don’t feel so much that just yet. Maybe it will change even in this season

Yeah agree 3-4 is a good record for a rebuilding team. But slowly I think that our record is waaay better then the team is. Our D is terrible other then 4-5 players. Deadlast at sacks (5 in 7 games are you kidding me-we might have 15 in whole year-Jared Allen alone will have more-can we trade the 5 picks to him instead of Harvey please???…)
All eyes on the offense now; and becaus we are inconsistent still it is veeeery tough to predict the jags. Plus I don’t like the way we lose game.. I knew that will be an L in the middle of the 3rd Quarter last sunday…But I’Mortimistic and I think The jaguars can manage to reach the 7-9/8-8 goal.

Thomas has one gooood game against the Titans on Week 4-other then that…well he is aged-“It’s a young mens game” Vic K. We need to start Monroe; although the matchup against Tamba Hali orries me even more then Bowe against the secondary….

Gene too made already mistakes-the biggest was signing the terrible Brian Russell…(In retrospect-I Know he is on IR) I would kept B-Dub….
Ticketsales: I agree. The NFL is blind, if they joking aand making fun over us because of the unsold tickets. Yeah in Phily or Dalls you have to need a miracle to get tickets. But nearly halűf of the league is struggling I guess. This is not the booming 90S. This is the crisisfull times of the end of the 2000’s. People should get that!

Vic is might got sick with the hatemails. I cannot blame him. I would been enough of that until now; and he still still doing it. I think he is starting to get tired from some elements of these days NFL. I think if the Jaguars have a big run; Near Superbowl or Superbowl -within 5 years-he will quit the business. I think he is waiting the last big storyy sadly.
I keep him as my NFL mentor. I have since then new mentors (For example many BCC members starting we guys like You Terry (and Chris&John&Collin); and guys like Jeff Lageman. But he have big role that I’M such a hardcore Jaguars fan today-so he will remain special-no matter that sometimes I disagree with him!

Oh yeah we need more River City Rage posts. I know he is probably veeery busy, but He is one of the Fantastic Four! We need more stuuf from Mr. Christopher Harris!

Yeah owners like J.Jones; D. Snyder will do everything to kill the NFL. I hope Goddell will be watching close. If this will be the big market teams sport-NFL will lose it’s NR 1 status soon. They should think like Jville mentality; not dallas-but I see less and less hope for that. MY obnly hope is-Jacksonville will be an NFL city for a veeeeery long time

(Sorry about my mistypings but it’s 5: 30 AM and I’m started too feeel the pain of being awake for long)

GREAT READ TERRY!!!!!!!!! THANKS VERY MUCH!!!!!

Can we expects some words from your mysterious man of wisdom; John in the near future???

(Sidenote: Oh my how many splling and somtime gramatic errors I made in the long one… I’M tired)

I agree with much of what you said. Unlike most here, amd Zoltan, I’m quite optimistic about Harvey. He sheds blocks and he hits hard. He is making progress. I think Shack Harris did the guy a severe disservice by trading away so much for him that the average Jags fan will never accept his play level as “meeting expectations”.

I’m been dissappointed in the overall o-line play, but I’m not sure who is fault. I expected more from this group of talented players. Whether David holds the ball too long or not, they contribute to his getting whacked too hard and too often. I don’t see him lasting the season.

Gene smith has deen a pretty decent job, although some of his free agent signings still reman to be -evaluated. He will make mistakes, every single GM/talent scout does. But, as long as he has more hits than misses, you is doing his job well.

Vic, I think has had to deal with too much “crap” from Gator fans this year. I think he has lost his cool completely. Did anyone listen to the JDR show on tuesday evening? Some guy phoned in to speak to Jack and at one point said something to the effect of (I’m paraphrasing now) :“you must remember, this is a gators town… we are used to a dynamic, exciting type of football where all the players are playing with commitment… why cant the Jags play like them?” When fans start holding the gators up as shining example of how NFL teams should play, well…. Lets face it, the Buccanneers would probably put 70+ points up on the Gators, but the Jags must play like them. Huh.

I’m still not sure if the team’s record makes the Jags look better than they are, or if 2 appalling games has made us think they are worse than they are. But, I accept that this is a re-building year, and there have been plenty of very promising signs for the future.

I also think he’s progressing well and after watching a few games… he gets double teamed A LOT and when that’s the case then someone else on the line or the linebackers need to step up and take advantage. I think this is where we miss Hayward… expect Gene to pick up a DE in FA and maybe even keep Hayward for depth.

I believe we touched on almost all of this last night so I’ll just focus on Vic and Gene.

Gene is a good GM, though I believe I pointed out a few months back it seemed this site wanted to put a 100 ft gold statue of him outside the stadium. Let’s at least wait until he builds a Super Bowl team.

On Vic, I think he’s just grown tired and detached this season. If the conversations I have with people when I tell them I help run a Jags blog go anything like what Vic get’s in emails every day, I can relate. There’s a serious disconnect in this city and it must be hard to be one of the lightning rods for it.

I have other issues with JDR. You’re correct that he isn’t a talent eval guy. But I also think he’s just another mediocre at best coach. “Audible gate” and the latest Tenn game is a perfect example.

In week 4 – we had a good gameplan and good execution and the result was a beatdown win. Now, coming out of the bye week, we were unprepared. It was obvious that this team did not self scout very well to change things up – they just hit the repeat button from week 4. Did it ever occur to JDR and gang that Tenn MIGHT make some adjustments to that? Hence my self scout comment and poor anticipation on what Tenn might do defensively. On offense, it was no mystery at all – we just have a shit D.

Also, JDR and gang didn’t reconginize that Tenn was baiting David? How do pro coaches miss that? How is that not a point of communicaiton in game? And why were there NO adjustments in game to deal with the issue?

This probably goes a long way to explaining his “awesome” divisional record year in and year out.

but it could be worst. I think Gene Smith has been a great addition to this team, and its not so much that he has made mistakes, its more like players have lets us down. I was never the biggest fan of signing Tra Thomas considering his age, but ANYTHING was better than Barnes ( I HATED HIM!!!). Tra I think is just being affected by his age, and the age of the defenders he needs to block.

Terry O’Brien’s aimless musings and shallow thoughts on the Jaguars.

That just sounds so silly to me.

JDR didn’t throw David under the bus if all he said was the truth and why did David not see what the Titans were doing.
Derrick Harvey is improving but he has a long way to go maybe we should have traded for Jarred Allen.
The Oline is young and gaining experience , Tra Thomas was suppose to be a stop gap tackle but then we got Monroe and all that changed they will get better with time.
Our GM is doing a good job cleaning up 5 years of bad drafting. He will need at least 2 more drafts and get limited free agents. There is a reason they are free agents either to old, slow or attitude, there are some who are good players just with the wrong team.
 I also miss a lot of the post from different readers I have been on the sight about a year or so and have gotten great and useful info from all

(Click on the link)

If we perform well on the defensive line this Sunday and we get a few sacks, please do not start preaching about how we are improving or may be improving. Kansas City’s offensive line is just that bad.

I’ve been reading Vic for the last couple of years and this year I really feel for him. All offseason he told us to temper our expectations, that this team will need time. He told us the talent level wasn’t that great, so did PK when he was interviewed by Vic at training camp. How frustrated would you be with a fan base that complains about the Jaguars struggles when you’ve tried to warn that same fan base months before it would happen? I think sometimes people forget is a human being and want to take out there frustration on him because he GIVES them that oppurtunity to do so. People also forget that the column is called “Ask Vic”, not tell Vic how things are or should be. I think people should think about the questions they ask and if that very same WHINEY question a million times before. The great thing about Ask Vic is we, the fans, make the column work. I wouldn’t say Vic has fallen off, but we give him nothing but negativity to work with.

I would like to see the Gator questions to stop being asked as much. Also I think Vic throws the Gators in his “All-Important Power Rankings” to be funny. He’s trying to lighten the mood of the column, like when he wouldn’t take the asterick off of the Patriots during their 16-0 season.