2010 NFL Draft: Jaguars reach into the well with 4 FCS picks
In one of the franchise's most important drafts in history, Jaguars GM Gene Smith seemingly made a draft specifically to give the middle finger to called draft "experts." The Jaguars made the most shocking pick in the Top 10 by bypassing on Notre Dame QB Jimmy Clausen, among others, to select Cal DT Tyson Alualu.
However, the more surprising part of Jacksonville's draft was the sheer number of non-Division I FBS (I-A) players. The Jaguars drafted four players who played in the lower end College Football's Division I, while no other team drafted more than two.
The Jaguars have always had an affinity for small school talents, such as Rashean Mathis and Derek Cox. However, never has one of their drafts relied so heavily on players from outside Division I FBS (I-A). While some have said the Alualu pick will make Gene famous, I believe if he manages to hit on all of these players, that's what will make him famous.
The player who will most likely see the field first is 5th round pick Austen Lane. Lane was described as a poor man's Jason Pierre-Paul, except he had the kind of production you would expect from a physical freak at his level. Lane will most likely see the field at left defensive end at first, while getting used to the NFL's level of competition.
If his physical ability can then translate to the NFL well enough, he does have the ability to switch to right defensive end. The one knock on Austen Lane is if you check out Football Outsiders SACKSEER, Lane doesn't meet one of their four requirements for a pass rusher. Lane ran a 4.44 short shuttle at the combine (a drill designed to measure quickness and reaction to a play). No elite edge rusher has ever emerged from any round in the NFL and ran less than a 4.42.
For more on SACKSEER, Click Here.
After Lane, James Madison KR Scotty McGee should see plenty of action. Just as Adam and I said on BCC Radio on Saturday, McGee will be a DB in the same way Brian Witherspoon was a DB. McGee will be the full time kick returner and will only see the field on defense if everyone else get's injured in a game. McGee took home All-Conference honors as a kick returner two years in a row and should provide the Jaguars a solid return man.
Southern Illinois RB Deji Karim is an interesting player. Built much like Maurice Jones-Drew, it seems Karim will be expected to push Rashad Jennings for carries as the spell back.
The only head scratcher of a pick was Central Arkansas DE Larry Hart. Hart could be described as Quentin Groves 2.0 and a better fit as a 3-4 OLB. There is some indication the Jags are putting the pieces together to make a permanent move to the 3-4, but that's another article for another day.
With all of this being said, I'm sure the casual Jaguar fan isn't happy with any of these picks. They'll say, "Why didn't we take Aaron Hernandez" or "We could've had Myron Rolle instead of a no name returner." It's just the nature of taking guys from lower divisions.
I'll just say this, remember everyone in this town who complained about the Jaguars taking Rashean Mathis over UF WR Taylor Jacobs in 2003? Well, does anyone remember Taylor Jacobs having a NFL career?
12 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Small Team Draft
It’s great to see the positives in the draft, especially when the world at large is knocking the Jaguars picks…but what if Gene has stumbled, and these picks are in fact what they appear to be to others, less than the best possible at the position they were drafted? I guess my concern is not with any particlar pick itself (with the exception of Larry Hart), but with the fact Gene went small school unknown with every pick! Surely their are athletes in the major conferences that can play football, but you wouldn’t know it by looking at this draft! Then Gene cuts all the competition on the DL to our picks, before we even see them compete! Great confidence in your picks…or insurance you can say “we drafted players who started for us”?
Welcome to the site
Currently Playing: God of War III
PS3 ID: Nole1021
by Jonathan Loesche on Apr 27, 2010 11:56 AM EDT up reply actions
Aaron Hernandez was never gonna be our pick...
not with MULTIPLE drug test failures in college. He either doesn’t care about the rules, or is oblivious. Either way not our type of person.
ESPN will NEVER get it...
They continually say “bad” character guys will wind up in Jax. Today it was (complete idiot) Mark Schlereth saying he feels TO will wind up here. Its infuriating that none of these talking heads can take a minute to learn that we are going for talented AND high character guys!!! They have no clue, they are becoming unwatchable.
I know what you mean
it’s like, the average smart guy on this site knows about twice as much about our team as anyone else in the national media.
I'm sitting in a casino right now
and if I had to bet, my money would be on TO not wearing Black and Teal, this season or ever. These " experts" may know a lot about a lot, but every time they open their mouths they show how little they know about the Jags.
I love how Gene got Ds and Fs for all his over-reaching and misguided picks.
Kind of puzzled...
As to what Gene’s reasoning is behind seeming to prefer small school talent over Div 1 talent. Especially with the city of Jax being slap in the middle of the strongest college football conference in our nation (SEC). Travel expense can’t be it…we find TONS of guys from California every season (3000+ miles away)…$$$ can’t be it. We have to pay a rookie drafted at 10 the same regardless of whether he attended a D1, D2 or D3 school. So, what is it, you think? I disect our roster every season, and I have to admit that small school talent dominates our roster. I know there are always “gems” out there, but we have to be honest and admit that guys play at small schools for a reason. I’m still a proud Jag true and thru, but I just wonder if we shortchange ourselves by sticking to this “small school preferred” strategy.
by 78hustla Jag on Apr 28, 2010 1:24 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
My take
Gene Smith is a scout’s scout. He loves finding diamonds in the ruff. We’re talking about a guy that is obsessed with evaluating talent. GS took the time to grade every single player in the NFL from top to bottom. He puts in immense time and has a vision of what a winning team looks like. He finds pieces that fit the vision and drafts them.
Small schools scare a lot of teams away but I think GS knows what he is doing. Zach Miller, Derek Cox, and Terrence Knighton were all small school prospects and they look promising. I get what you’re saying about the lack of competition but I think GS kind of has a way to evaluate that to an extent.
by MikeThomasSlotReceiver on Apr 28, 2010 2:32 AM EDT up reply actions
I think it's kinda the other way around.
I think a lot of other teams shortchange themselves by only looking at players from the power conferences. It’s why the Jaguars, and not other teams, get to benefit from the talents of Rashean Mathis, Jurant Durant, Paul Spicer, Cox, Knighton, etc. You find football players where you find them, and I like having the confidence that the Jaguars’ scouting department sorts through EVERYONE and doesn’t have a bias about where a certain player played.
In Gene We Trust.
by MoveThoseChains on Apr 28, 2010 7:48 AM EDT up reply actions
Yep
Let’s just fill up our roster with guys from the big schools, damn whatever scouts say. Nevermind the overwhelming majority of people on the Jags roster are still from BCS conference schools.
Currently Playing: God of War III
PS3 ID: Nole1021
by Jonathan Loesche on Apr 28, 2010 8:05 AM EDT up reply actions

by 






























