Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Sixers Vs. Celtics: Countdown To Game Seven

In Gene We Trust


After the 2008 season the Jaguars were in tough spot. Years worth of poor draft picks, free agent selections and lack accountability had placed the team at the bottom of the AFC South with little chance of improving. Wayne Weaver made the decision to cut ties with Vice President of Player Personnel Shack Harris who was seen as directly responsible for the Jaguars predicament and promote Gene Smith to General Manager. This promotion gave the Jaguars a bonafide GM and as Jonathan Loesche explained that the move meant "Smith is in charge of buying the groceries and Del Rio is in charge of who cooks the meal.". Since he was promoted a lot has changed in regards to the Jaguars but if there is one thing that we have learned is that we are never gonna know what Gene Smith is thinking.

Star-divide

 

Gene's first step as GM, cut ties with anyone who did not show good character, was not needed or was a Shack Harris era bust. Smith started by purging the roster, getting rid of or not resigning players such as Matt Jones, Mike Peterson, Gerald Sensabaugh, Drayton Florence Reggie Williams, Khalif Barnes, Paul Spicer and even letting go of Fred Taylor. Smith did not give special treatment to players he simple acted on what he thought was the best moves for the Jaguars. In their place he brought in aging veterans Tra Thomas and Torry Holt (ala the Patriots) to help improve the team but also act as mentors. The 2009 Draft gave Jaguars fans the first look at what a Gene Smith Draft was like, unpredictable. The first pick by the Jaguars, Eugene Monroe, was a no brainer but after that Smith showed everyone he was willing to stick to his draft board and pick whoever he personally thought was the best pick available not who Mel Kiper Jr. thought was best available. Smith took Britten in the second round showing he was focusing on improving the trenches and then picked Terrance Knighton in the 3rd. Then he shocked most of the NFL when he traded up to get Derek Cox, the CB no one in the media had heard of. Smith simply didn't care, he had the guys he wanted and he picked them plan and simple. I personally got satisfaction in watching Mel Kiper Jr. have a near heartattack when Gene Smith threw is draft board out of whack with the Cox pick. 

In his second offseason as GM, Gene Smith once again showed everyone that he going to do what he wants to do and he is going to be unpredictable. When most of the Jaguars fans including most at BCC thought that Smith was going to keep relatively quiet during free agency, he made two major splashes with the signings of Kassim Osgood and Aaron Kampman. It was at that this point that even though Smith has been unpredictable we start to see a decent pattern in his moves. Holt, Thomas, Osgood, and Kampman have been his major free agent signings and all are either hardworking, leaders, or both. Smith has shown a willingness to give chances and take risks on high character players who have shown that they are willing to put in the extra effort. Entering the 2010 draft most people had about 4 or 5 different players pegged as the Jaguars potential pick ranging from C.J. Spiller to Derrick Morgan. When the Jaguars picked Tyson Alualu it stunned everyone and every media outlet started attacking the pick as too high and a huge reach. You know what though Gene Smith didn't care. As Mel had another melt down because his mock draft had once again but busted by Smith, Smith talked up his pick. He then went on to pick 3 more defensive lineman in consecutive picks showing everyone that when he was willing to do what ever he thought was necessary to fix a problem area. While the media attacked some of his early round moves Smith worked some of  his magic later on with trades to bring in Kirk Morrison and an extra draft pick for 2011. With the arrival of all these new young lineman Smith even released John Henderson, who had shown a little lack of effort at times and had been called out by Jack Del Rio.

By the time the 2010 season started Gene Smith had retooled most the team. Each offseason he seemed to pick an area of need and focus on it. In the 2009 it was the Offensive Line and 2010 it was the Defensive Line and all the while he signed free agents and brought it later round draft picks to help shore up other areas. In two years Gene Smith had transformed the Jaguars from an aging, struggling, and sometimes characterless team (heres looking at you Matt Jones and Reggie Williams) to a young, upcoming and high chemistry team. Even though the Jaguars did not make the playoffs and dropped their last 3 games, you can just see the difference in the team from the end of 2008 and now. When the Jaguars lost to the Ravens at the end of the 2008 season we as fans saw a lot of finger pointing and sulking when the season ended. Even though the lose to the Texans to end this season was disappointing, we saw a different reaction by the players. They took responsibility for the lose and seemed optimistic about the future. The players even came to Jack Del Rios defense when his job was in questions that they wanted him to stay because they believe "something special" was forming. That type of optimism was not present before Gene took over. He has put together a great group of core players who work hard, take responsibility for their actions and look to lead.

We are now entering the third offseason with Gene Smith at the helm. Everyone knows the secondary is a major hole on this team, can we expect a Gene Smith purge and remolding of the secondary? We will have to wait and see. Will he once again surprise us with a free agency pick up or cutting of an established veteran? Who knows. What players will the Jaguars look to draft this year? Only Gene Smith really knows.The only thing that we know is whatever Gene Smith does do will be probably something we can't predict but will end up being best for the Jaguars organization because even though the Jaguars season is over sooner then I hoped, for the first time in a while I am still excited to see what this group of guys can do next season. In Gene We Trust.


-Kterr

Poll
With two full seasons down, how would you rate Gene Smith's performance as GM?
A
104 votes
B
71 votes
C
11 votes
D
1 votes
F
3 votes
Incomplete
7 votes

197 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 21 comments  |  5 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Rec'd good article...

Kassim Osgood*, and I believe Gene will purge most of the secondary besides, Cox and Greene.

by rhettchrystal on Jan 10, 2011 2:56 PM EST reply actions  

Thanks! Fixed

"I’m going to punish him. If he hits me, fine, but if I catch him, believe me, I’m going to get the better shot." - Fred Taylor

by kterr on Jan 10, 2011 3:00 PM EST up reply actions  

Good Article.

and I feel the same way, for the first time in a long time I’m looking forward to the draft and free agency more than worried about it.

by Sylvester.The.Jaguar.fan on Jan 10, 2011 3:06 PM EST reply actions  

+500

everything hes done ive liked, hes put in a huge effort to help the franchise and i love it..i am probably going to the draft this year, so i hope he doesnt disappoint and puts together a winning team for next year. We have a very hard schedule, and this is clearly Jack’s last season if we dont make the playoffs..in Gene we Trust !

by FgallosJAGS on Jan 10, 2011 3:32 PM EST reply actions  

Fgallos

If you go to the draft you should do a diary on here or something.
Fair summation of Gene’s work thus far. Fingers crossed for a good offseason.

What could of happened; did.

by Mullayo on Jan 10, 2011 4:29 PM EST up reply actions  

I voted C

I gave him a C. His first draft had four “hits” (Monroe, Knighton, Thomas, Jennings). I’m still iffy on Britton & Cox and I don’t think Underwood is any good.

His second draft I think looks much worse, right now. Alualu was solid, but faded. The rush defense was still poor. Larry Hart flashed prior to the season but didn’t do a whole lot when the season was on going. Austen Lane become a starter, but that’s not really a big positive. I thought Lane was rather blah as a starter. Not horrible, but nothing really stood out aside from his motor. Karim was great as a kick returner, but you also have another kick returner on IR. I still question taking two special teams guys. The draft was defense heavy, but the defense got worse. This draft has a chance to look a lot better with the maturation of Alualu, how D’Anthony Smith pans out, and if Lane/Hart wind up anything more than role players.

by Alfie Crow on Jan 10, 2011 4:34 PM EST reply actions  

Is this a C for Smith's job as a whole, or Smith's drafts?

I’d probably give him a B-/C+ in the draft and an A-/B+ in free agency. Holt and Thomas were the veteran presences we expected in their one year here. Kampman looked like a huge hit until he got injured. Osgood was Osgood. Considine was a solid depth signing. He also grabbed Courtney Greene, Jason Hill, and William Middleton off the scrap heap. I’d probably give him a B with the potential for an A-/B+ overall.

Contributor for Big Cat Country

Follow me on Twitter if you feel like it.

Formerly Gallagher's Watermelons and Player To Be Named Later

by CaliforniaJag on Jan 11, 2011 2:07 PM EST up reply actions  

Do you think Tyson played more than he was expected to?

I think he played about 85% of the defensive snaps this year.

by Joe Fisher on Jan 22, 2011 11:55 PM EST up reply actions  

I gave a C alos

Monroe is decent but really not worth a top ten…Cox will never be able to cover a number one guy….Just cause defenses do not throw his way is because we have holes all over the place…

Alualu did fade…I want to think its his conditioning but really he was mostly blocked by one guy…That hardly represents a top ten pick…Especially when everyone was handling him pretty easy…

Mike Thomas was jackpot though…The little quick guys are the way to go now…Welker, Woodhead, Thomas…

I would love Gene if he got cam newton and a shutdown bd through free agency….and a killer OLB…3 things not much…We get Newton in the draft…

by justkizzit on Jan 11, 2011 11:02 AM EST reply actions  

Umm..

Monroe’s only bad game this year was philly, If it wasn’t for Garrard holding the ball a little to long on two plays, Mario Williams and Freeney would have had no impact on either one of those games.. I’d say thats worth a top ten pick.
 
Alualu was almost never blocked by one guy and was ridiculously held for most of the year.. I do think with a good conditioning program in the offseason he could get a lot better and gain some more explosiveness but if you want Cam Newton, then you were probably the same kind of person that wanted Tebow so it wouldn’t matter how good Alualu does, you’ll hate him.

by Sylvester.The.Jaguar.fan on Jan 11, 2011 12:00 PM EST up reply actions  

Monroe got beat by alot of guys this year..And I did watch alualu get manhandled one on one by guys you never heard of....TO call he was held well welcome the the NFL...You want to bolster the interior...Get the big guy from Auburn in the middle...

If you don’t think cam Newton is a good prospect dont know what to say to that either…I think he makes good decisions with teh ball as far as I have seen. Sees the filed well and can pocket pass…I think he would grow well under Garrard for a year…

by justkizzit on Jan 11, 2011 1:05 PM EST up reply actions  

Monroe was fantastic. His only bad game was the Eagles.

by Alfie Crow on Jan 12, 2011 9:13 AM EST via mobile up reply actions  

im with u justkizzit

we need one of the best if not the best OLB in college football. We got some good ends and potroast is solid. Tyson needs to step up. We also need to get these DB’s together. Mathis is playing like he doesnt give a *^%&. Cox is ok, if you put him in the right place with the right play calling he’ll make a play. Carey is the biggest bum ever. He makes Nelson looks like Ed Reed. So throw Carey to the wolves for supper. Greene is solid. So this leaves Gene to sign a hell of a DB in free agency. Champ, Joseph, or Asomogha. We can move Mathis to Free Safety. Hopefully that can work. Morrison cant cover a 3 month old baby with a blanket. I see why Oakland got rid of him. Durrant hasnt done much. So thats where the OLB draft pick comes in to play.

by Ryan North on Jan 11, 2011 12:01 PM EST up reply actions  

I think we need to let the 3rd season play out

Monroe, Knighton, Thomas and Jennings have proven themselves as quality picks. Monroe has had his poor games but I have also watched him play lights out at times. Cox has also been up and down and I wanna see him next season before I judge. We really don’t know much from the 2010 draft yet. I like Alualu and though he faded down the stretch I attribute that too the lose of Kampman and general wear and tear. Alualu is a worker and I good character guy so I am not worried about him coming into next season ready to roll. Other the Deji Karim though the 2010 draft doesn’t look that great unless Hart and Lane mature and improve. I think it is going to depend on the return of D’Anthony Smith and Scotty McGee. Smith has potential and might improve Alualu if he can consistently give Alualu more rest if Smith can perform well in a rotation. McGee will just make our super special teams even better, his return ability I think will make McGee and Karim one of the best return duos in the league. Overall I give Gene Smith a B- on drafts so far with room to improve. His free agent pick ups are at A in my book. Thomas, Holt, Kampman and Osgood provided veteran leadership and quality play which is what this team needed. Plus I liked the addition of Hill, if he stays he might become a good weapon. Overall I think Gene should look to add a CB, Safety, and a Guard through either the draft or free agency. We can pick up a QB, but I would rather wait until the 4th round for one unless the value warrants it (i.e. if Mallet or someone falls to us). I voted B for Smith as I think a combination of his drafts and free agent pick ups have given the Jaguars a young, good character core that will be around for a while.

"I’m going to punish him. If he hits me, fine, but if I catch him, believe me, I’m going to get the better shot." - Fred Taylor

by kterr on Jan 11, 2011 2:33 PM EST up reply actions  

well since he's come back off the bench

hes been playing very well, playing tight on Dez Bryant, shtuting him down, jumping routes, and sticking with his man

by rhettchrystal on Jan 11, 2011 7:58 PM EST up reply actions  

Not worth a top ten? Do you know how lucky we are to even have him on this team? He was one of the top three tackles of that draft, with him being the most balanced of them. He was the only one that was touted as being equally good at pass protection as he is at run blocking. It’s taking time for him to master his pass protection technique, but eventually he’ll be able to block the most elite pass rushers. So I disagree, he was definately worth the pick.

by kjones407 on Jan 13, 2011 8:33 AM EST up reply actions  

Alualu didn't fade...

….the lack of a good MLB, didn’t help the run D, Knighton and Alualu clogged their gaps, and Morrison just sat back in his spot, and got juked out, instead of running up, and cutting the back down before he breaks out….

by rhettchrystal on Jan 11, 2011 7:57 PM EST reply actions  

what about

Zach Miller – that was a helluva good pick…If Britton turns into a solid starter then that draft is monstrous – I never did like the Cox move though….Syill dont get it. They could have waited and got him in the 5th or 6th round – You can’t fall in love with a guy and overdraft him – especially giving up next years 2 for this years 3…Hart was also a bad pick – We have had numerous Tweeners – the Smith kid and several others I cant even remember…Lane is just OK….Put 30 pounds on him and move him inside. D’Anthiny Smiths recovery will have a huge impact on last years draft….Not a fan of the Deji and McGee picks either…I think Gene knows what he is doing but he reaches too often – Alualu is solid but again – we overdrafted a kid that was a 2/3 round player….Earl Thomas was sitting right there… Go Jags! Anyone can second guess after the fact tho – and I am glad we have Gene here.

Chad

by chadguar on Jan 21, 2011 3:03 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Big Cat Country:: Jacksonville Jaguars news, commentary, speculation and fun, all from a fan's perspective

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Chastin West
Small
Brian Robiskie ?
Small
Blaine Gabbert: What Can Be Done? (Part 1)
015_small
My issue with college football
Small
Blaine Gabbert Video Sampler Platter
Small
Interested in joining an all-time NFL mock draft?
Hurricane1_small
2012 Game-by-Game Predictions
Kiwi-new2_small
Mullayo's May 53 man roster
Chester_cheeto_small
The New QB Dilemna
Small
SeminoleKid's 53 man roster

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Manager

77312417837578290_small River City Rage

180103_10150110239888826_529758825_6295646_8155374_n_small Adam Stites

Image_small Alfie Crow

Editor-in-Chief

Img_6121_small silencecs

Contributor

404931_2894108066464_1073166201_32535141_1775032715_n_small CaliforniaJag

32213_924639348222_5111476_51082025_729592_n_small T.Holmes

Twitter_pic_small Shane Clemons

Small Michael Appelbaum

P9260123_small Jagfan89

Cole_small theeCodyTaylor