If I had been drafting for the Jacksonville Jaguars...
As we are nearly into the month of April and the 2011 NFL Draft being only 5 weeks away, I wanted to take a look back at past drafts. Not necessarily to look at the horror of bad drafting, but to just compare and contrast and how my mock drafts looked versus what the Jacksonville Jaguars actually drafted. I don't want to hurt my arm patting myself on the back, but I think the team would have been much better off with my picks in the draft. Oh, and the SBNation.com's writers mock draft begins today.
I stole this idea from Brian Galliford over at Buffalo Rumblings, by the way.
2006 NFL Draft
We'll start all the way back in 2006, because I can only remember one mock draft pick and I can't get deep enough into the JagNation.com archives to find out who we picked in the second round, but I know it wasn't Maurice Jones-Drew. I believe we actually had him going to the Colts with their first round pick. How scary would that have been?
| Rd. | My Pick | Jaguars Pick |
| 1 | TE Marcedes Lewis, UCLA | TE Marcedes Lewis, UCLA |
This wasone of the easiest Jaguars draft picks to peg that I can remember. The Jaguars really needed a pass catching threat at the TE position to go with the wide receivers they drafted, as they were building around then quarterback Byron Leftwich. Lewis was actually a perfect blend of need and value in that draft.
2007 NFL Draft
This draft was an interesting one to mock for the Jacksonville Jaguars. The Jaguars originally picked 17th and wound up trading down with the Denver Broncos. The Broncos selected defensive end Jarvis Moss, who quite a few had mocked to the Jaguars that year.
| Rd. | My Picks | Jaguars Picks |
| 1 | LB Lawrence Timmons, FSU | FS Reggie Nelson, Florida |
| 2 | QB Kevin Kolb, Houston | LB Justin Durant, Hampton |
We knew the Jaguars were looking to inject some youth in the linebacker position and I felt like Lawrence Timmons would be a nice fit as an atheltic linebacker. I knew the Jaguars were hot for Kevin Kolb talking to some of the scouts I knew. This was also when the souring on Byron Leftwich really began and I didn't think David Garrard was the answer. This is the year I began beating the draft a quarterback drum, and if Kolb had made it to the Jaguars pick, I feel pretty confident saying they'd have drafted him.
2008 NFL Draft
The 2008 off-season had the Jaguars thinking they were right on the cusp of a Super Bowl berth and would challenge for the division. Obviously the pass rush was a big area of concern then, just like it is now.
| Rd. | My Picks | Jaguars Picks |
| 1 | DE Calais Campbell, Miami | DE Derrick Harvey, Florida |
| 2 | CB/S Charles Godfrey, Iowa | DE Quentin Groves, Auburn |
As we know, almost anything aside from what the Jaguars picked in 2008 could have been better than what it turned out. I picked Campbell because he was a versatile strong side end who could also rush the passer from the inside. Turns out he's a nice fit in the 3-4 for the Cardinals. I like Charles Godfrey a lot as a safety instead of corner and thought he'd pair nicely with Reggie Nelson who had a really nice rookie season.
2009 NFL Draft
This was a real interesting draft because it was the first one with general manager Gene Smith. We weren't sure of his tendencies, but we had an idea he wasn't going to be swinging at guys like Michael Crabtree like a lot of Jaguars fans wanted. I knew he had an eye for Mark Sanchez, but I didn't envision him falling to the Jaguars. Sure enough, the Jets jumped up and snapped him else I think Gene Smith would have taken him. We also knew left tackle was a big need for the Jaguars with Khalif Barnes hitting free agency despite signing Tra Thomas.
| Rd. | My Picks | Jaguars Picks |
| 1 | DT B.J. Raji, Boston College | OT Eugene Monroe, Virginia |
| 2 | SS Louis Delmas, Western Michigan | OT Eben Britton, Arizona |
I never thought Monroe would make it to the 8 slot and most had the Jaguars taking Jason Smith at the 8 spot, who I was never a big fan of. I thought Raji presented great value for the Jaguars who's age was showing on the defensive line. I wanted to go back to the safety well again with Delmas, because Reggie Nelson was still struggling and Delmas reminded me a lot of Colts safety at the time, Bob Sanders.
2010 NFL Draft
In the 2010 draft, no one really knew where Gene Smith would go. A lot of people (including myself) thought Jimmy Clausen was a real possibility at the 10 spot, but most people didn't think he'd even make it there. Turns out he made it all the way to the second round. C.J. Spiller was also a popular thought at the position, but I never understood that line of thinking consider Maurice Jones-Drew had just gotten a contract and was coming off a Pro-Bowl season. Linebacker Rolando McClain was also a popular choice.
| Rd. | My Pick | Jaguars Pick |
| 1 | CB Joe Haden, Florida | DT Tyson Alualu, California |
I took Joe Haden in the SBNation.com writer's mock draft last year because I thought he was great value there. I thought long and hard about safety Earl Thomas as well. Even though Derek Cox had a decent rookie season, I thought someone like Haden would shore up the cornerback spot for the long term and kill two birds with one stone allowing Rashean Mathis to move to the safety position. Obviously Tyson Alualu came out of nowhere, but so far he looks like he'll work out.
I must say however, I think if I had been GM I'd have made some money with my first round picks.
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Oh, we're playing this game?
So your picks were mostly guys who weren’t even available when the Jaguars picked? Congrats??
BTW, last year I had them taking Ndamukong Suh. So I really look smart.
Must... not... feed ..trolls.......
by KillJag on Mar 28, 2011 10:32 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Trolls by pointing out facts? Most of the guys he listed were not even available when the Jaguars picked.
by Fivus Viener on Mar 28, 2011 11:07 AM EDT up reply actions
No....
A troll by the way you presented your arguments to his story. You came off like a complete a-hole, if you’re going to argue in this type of setting you would do good to employ a little more etiquette. No matter how valid your points may be when you act like you did your arguments carry much less weight.
by KillJag on Mar 28, 2011 11:26 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Yes, because Suh being available at 10 was very realistic a day or so before the draft.
by Alfie Crow on Mar 28, 2011 10:37 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Despite what ^ that guy says, I enjoyed this. Sure, a good few of those guys weren’t there but at least for the most part he picked good players. I can’t even imagine what our team would have been like if Alfie’s 2007 draft actualy happened for us.
In 2007 I thought Reggie Nelson would be the pick.
2008- Philip Merling
2009 – Changed from originally being trading with the Jets who take Sanchez and we than grab Cushing at 16, later changed to Marc Sanchez and finally ended at BJ Raji.
2010- Rolando McClain than Joe Haden.
Didn't Raji have some of those dreaded "character concerns"
Dude was a hell of a talent coming out of college.
More like height concerns...
Yeah, I believe he failed a drug test. It was all those pots he’d been smokin’.
It was reported he failed the drug test at the combine, but that wound up false.
by Alfie Crow on Mar 28, 2011 2:06 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Character concerns? Yes, even from readers of this site.
http://www.bigcatcountry.com/2009/3/31/815969/analysis-of-bj-raji-interview
by Fivus Viener on Mar 28, 2011 2:17 PM EDT up reply actions
2008 set us back big time
Alfie did you have a full mock for any of those years?
Just saying cause our tackle situation would be dire by now…
What could of happened; did.
This is an interesting exercise
Another interesting one would be to try to recall who you were hoping they’d pick at each pick right after the pick and see how that would’ve gone. For example, when the Jaguars were on the clock at 10 last year I was personally hoping for Brandon Graham. Going back several years (our pick in parentheses)…
2005
1. Mark Clayton (Matt Jones)
2. Dan Cody (Khalif Barnes)
3. Marion Barber III (Scott Starks)
2006
1. Mathias Kiwanuka (Marcedes Lewis)
2. Darryl Tapp (Maurice Jones-Drew…D’OH!)
2007
1. Reggie Nelson (Reggie Nelson. Dammit.)
2. Victor Abiamiri (Justin Durant)
3. Charles Johnson (Mike Sims-Walker…anyone notice my DE fetish yet?)
2008
1. This one’s weird because of the huge trade. Going into the draft I wanted Antoine Cason. Once we traded into the 8 spot I didn’t really have a “want”; I knew the pick was going to be Derrick Harvey.
2. Chad Henne (Quentin Groves)
2009
1. Eugene Monroe (Eugene Monroe…I thought he was the second-best player in the entire draft going in and was stoked that he fell to us)
2. Darius Butler (Eben Britton)
3a. Antoine Caldwell (Terrance Knighton)
3b. Antoine Caldwell (Derek Cox)
2010
1. Brandon Graham (Tyson Alualu)
3. Bruce Campbell (D’Anthony Smith)
Some of these would’ve been decent, but some would’ve really sucked. Do you remember who you wanted back when the Jags were on the clock?
CORRELATION DOES NOT IMPLY CAUSATION
Contributor for Big Cat Country
Follow me on Twitter if you feel like it.
Love the idea Alfie
Because I always think about this come draft season. Usually I can’t remember who my later round hopefuls are, but I do remember my board when the first round pick came up…
2003:
1a – Terrell Suggs
1b – Jordan Gross
I really, really wanted Suggs. Leftwich blindsided me. Later, Leftwich was blindsided often.
2004:
1a – Lee Evans
1b – Kenechi Udeze
1c – Jonathan Vilma
Again, the Williams pick drove me crazy. Clearly, Udeze would have been worse.
2005:
1a – Mark Clayton
1b – Marlin Jackson
1c – Roddy White
Though I wasn’t “targeting” him, I kind of liked the splash pick with Matt Jones. Lesson learned – splash picks are terrible.
2006:
I was at this draft in NY, and was so busy enjoying (and not tracking) that I didn’t really know who was available. All I remember was wanting DeAngelo Williams to fall, and he didn’t. I would probably have been indifferent on any pick, because the Jags missed out on Williams.
Side note: I remember thinking LenDale White was going to be a better pro than Reggie Bush. Loved his goal-line ability in those USC games.
2007:
1a – Jarvis Moss (was available before Broncos trade)
1b – Reggie Nelson
1c – Brady Quinn
Yikes. Double yikes. Triple yikes. The year I hope to (but can’t) forget.
2008:
1a – Kenny Phillips
1b – Calais Campbell
1c – Mario Manningham
1d – Chad Henne
I weep at the thought of this draft. Pretending we had kept our pick in the 20’s, my board would have looked something like the above. I remember loving Aqib Talib, but he was gone by the time we (would have) picked.
2009:
1a – Eugene Monroe
1b – B.J. Raji
1c – Malcolm Jenkins
I wanted the Jaguars to get out of the draft with either Monroe or Raji, and I thought only Raji would fall. Jenkins was my last-resort pick. This draft helped atone for my scouting deficiencies previously.
2010:
1a – Brandon Graham
1b – Earl Thomas
I was vehemently opposed to Derrick Morgan and JPP, though most mocks had us taking one or the other.
2011:
1a – Cameron Jordan
1b – Aldon Smith
1c – Prince Amukamara
1d – Jake Locker
1e – Gabe Carimi (all-else-fails pick)
Thanks if anyone’s still reading.

by 































